I read Hannah’s last sentence again.
Mark said he’d make sure I never got the chance.
Audrey was looking over my shoulder. I wanted to fold the note before she saw the fear in those words, but she had already read them.
“Grandma,” she said, “what did he do to her?”
“I don’t know.”
I hated how little comfort that answer offered. I remembered Mark at the hospital, standing near the vending machines with his hands pressed together. I’d thought he was frightened for Hannah. A week later, when he left Audrey with me, I’d thought he was overwhelmed by grief.
Now I didn’t know what I’d been looking at.
I laid the note on my sewing table and searched the cabinet again. Behind a folded quilt sat a thin notebook. Hannah had written Audrey’s first year on the cover.
Only the first few pages were filled. They held the things she’d hoped to remember: the day she first felt Audrey kick, the lullaby she sang in the car, the way she’d suddenly started craving peaches.
The last page was dated three days before the birth.
I showed Mark the message on Daniel’s phone. He knew exactly what it said before I read it aloud. I asked him how. He told me I was tired and imagining things.
Below that, squeezed into the margin, she’d added:
Daniel didn’t send it. I need to apologize to him.
I reached for my phone.
Daniel answered before the second ring.
“I found another note,” I said. “Hannah believed Mark had interfered with the message on your phone. She meant to tell you at the hospital.”
For a moment he said nothing. Then, quietly, “I would have been there.”
“I know.”
Audrey touched my arm. “Tell him what Mark said.”
I read him the final line of the note. His voice changed.
“Are you and Audrey at home?”
“Yes.”
“Is Mark there?”
“We haven’t seen him in fifteen years.”
“That’s good,” Daniel said. “Please keep the door locked. I’ll come if you want me to.”
Audrey held out her hand. “I want to talk to him.”
I gave her the phone. This time she carried it to the living room, and I let her speak without me beside her.
I took photographs of Hannah’s notes and put the originals back in their envelopes. Then I called the hospital where she had died. After a long wait, a records clerk explained how to request the old medical file. She couldn’t tell me what it contained over the phone.
It would take days.
I didn’t want to wait days.
I opened the last drawer of the cabinet, the one that always stuck. Inside were the papers I’d brought home after Hannah’s funeral: hospital forms, a sympathy card from the nurses, and a photograph taken the morning we left for the delivery.
Hannah stood in my kitchen, laughing at the size of the bag I’d packed for her. Behind her, on the counter, lay a white envelope with Daniel’s name written across it.
I stared at that envelope. In the photograph, its flap was open.
The one Daniel found behind his drawer had been sealed.
Audrey came back while I was still looking at it.
“Daniel’s coming over,” she said. “I told him I wanted him to.”
“All right.”
“He said I could change my mind when he gets here.”
“That sounds fair.”
She stood beside me and looked at the photograph. “Mom looks happy.”
“She was nervous,” I said. “But yes. She was happy.”
I wished I could give Audrey that morning back: Hannah laughing, asking whether we had room for one more blanket, checking the mirror to see if her hair looked all right for a picture with her baby.
“Do you think Mark hurt her?” Audrey asked.
“I think Hannah was afraid of him. I’m going to find out why.”
A car slowed outside. Both of us turned toward the window, but it kept going.
I put the photograph down and called my friend Ellen. She’d been the nurse on duty when Hannah arrived at the hospital. We hadn’t spoken about that day in years.
Ellen answered warmly, then went quiet when I told her what I’d found.
“I remember Mark,” she said.
“What do you remember?”
“He came to the desk and asked which room Hannah was in. I thought he was the baby’s father.” She paused. “But Hannah asked me to keep him out.”
I gripped the edge of the table. “She did?”
“She said she wanted you with her. She was very clear about Mark.”
“Did you tell anyone?”
“I told the nurse taking over my shift. Then Hannah’s labor became urgent, and everything moved fast.”
I closed my eyes. I’d been at Hannah’s side for most of it. But there had been a few minutes when a doctor asked me to step out. Mark had been in the hallway then.
“Ellen, do you remember whether he went into her room?”
“I didn’t see him go in,” she said. “I’m sorry. I should have told you she asked about him. After she died, I thought you already knew.”
I thanked her and ended the call.
A knock sounded at the front door.
Audrey looked at me. “Daniel?”
Through the window beside the door, I saw a man about Hannah’s age now, holding a photograph in both hands. He stood well back from the porch light, as though he didn’t want to seem like he was pushing his way into our lives.
I opened the door.
Daniel looked first at me, then at Audrey. His face crumpled.
“She has Hannah’s eyes,” he whispered.
Audrey took one step forward. Daniel stayed where he was.
“You brought the picture?” she asked.
He held it out. Hannah stood outside the bakery in her green coat, grinning over a paper bag. Across the bottom, in her handwriting, were the words Audrey wanted cinnamon rolls.
Audrey touched the edge of the photograph.
For a while, neither of them said anything.
Then Daniel looked at me. “I brought Hannah’s letter, too. The one I found behind my drawer.”
I led him inside. At the kitchen table, he unfolded the letter while Audrey sat across from him, holding the photograph in her lap.
“I read it so many times this morning,” he said. “I kept thinking I’d missed something.”
He handed it to me.
The first page was just as he’d described: Hannah apologizing and asking him to come to my house after Audrey was born. But along the fold at the bottom, I noticed a faint line of ink that didn’t match her handwriting.
I held the page nearer the lamp.
There were numbers there, pressed so hard into the paper that they’d left a mark from whatever Hannah had written on top of it.
“Do you have a pencil?” Daniel asked.
I brought one from my sewing room. He laid the letter on the table and shaded lightly across the indented lines.
A phone number appeared. Beneath it were four words.
Ask for the night nurse.
Ellen had worked the day shift.
I reached for my phone, but before I could dial, Audrey pointed to the bottom of the page.
“There’s more.”
Daniel moved the pencil once more. A final sentence came into view, faint but unmistakable.
She saw Mark switch the bags……………………….
One Comment on “PART 4 — THE MAN WHO WAS THERE WHEN HANNAH DIED”